Blueberry Pancake Cereal Milk Milkshake


Growing up, we never had any “fun” cereal around the house (much to my extreme chagrin and utter disappointment).

We had things like Raisin Bran and Mini Wheats and on very rare occasion, Apple Jacks – which don’t get me wrong, are all fine and dandy and things that I enjoy very much in my adult life, but as a kid they contributed to my consistent and overwhelming struggles with FCFOMO (aka, Fun Cereal FOMO).


The closest thing we had to Cocoa Puffs was when my brother drizzled Hershey’s syrup on top of a bowl of Kix, which was basically heaven and a tactic that I fully intend to employ with my own children someday, but also no substitute for dehydrated blue marshmallows in the shapes of hearts and moons.


Because I’m still recovering psychologically from this obvious and crushing deprivation, today I’ve pretty much made it my life’s mission to try ALL the sugary cereals (which is a very smart move now that I’m 30 and my formerly okay-ish metabolism is quickly evaporating into thin air). But not being one to let petty nutritional obstacles bring me down, I persevere! Especially when the universe offers up pure magic, such as this sparkly new Cap’n Crunch variety:

Screen Shot 2018-02-21 at 9.52.09 PM
Image courtesy

This cereal combines two things that I love dearly 1) sugar and 2) sugar that tastes like artificially flavored maple syrup (shout out Log Cabin! #rideordie). When Hubs saw this on Snackstalker or some other delightful Instagram account, I immediately placed an online order for two giant family-sized boxes. When the package finally arrived, this blue and yellow baby did NOT disappoint – it tasted like the Fun Cereal version of blueberry pancakes!

(Please note the carefully crafted verbiage “Fun Cereal version” – please don’t go into this thinking you’re getting Wild Maine Blueberry essence, people. Manage your expectations).


Though quite good when eaten by the handfuls, this flavor really sang when mellowed out with a little 2% milk. In a true moment of divine ice cream intervention, the clouds parted and I found my next inspiration. I just knew in my soul that this cereal was meant to become a milkshake!


Don’t worry – I know I’m not being super original over here; the idea of “Cereal Milk” isn’t really a new thing, at all. But even so, I’ve been rather disappointed with some of the more commercial executions I’ve tasted recently. Case in point? Burger King’s “Fruit Loop” shake (and yes, I realize that by addressing this grievance I’m openly admitting that I am indeed a Burger King customer from time to time. But I mean, do YOU make good life decisions when you’re on a road trip and your Service Plaza options are limited to BK, Auntie Anne’s, and Hardees? Didn’t think so).


The key to anything “cereal milk” flavored – whether it be ice cream, milkshakes, baked goods, etc. – is to actually use the cereal milk in your creation (duh, right?). What I mean is that you must infuse (fancy culinary word alert!) milk with your cereal of choice – basically, you’re just leaving a bowl of cereal in the fridge for one to two hours so the pieces get nice and soggy and the liquid has that delicious, sweet flavor.


It seems simple enough, yet so many cereal milk-labeled items miss this key step, and what you end up with is just vanilla ice cream with cereal pieces. But never fear, dear reader – NOT like this milkshake. This milkshake is chock full of diabetes-inducing sweetness, pretty yellow and blue swirls, and most importantly – actually tastes like the cereal itself.


I finished this one with a dusting of sea salt, which helps cut through the rich sweetness and creates more of a savory shake (because we should always try to bring a little pretention to the table, no matter what – even when we’re using kid cereal).


I hope you love this super simple yet unquestionably delicious way to get your Fun Cereal fix for the day. Feel free to swap in your favorite Fun Cereal (…except maybe Mini Wheats – not sure how that one will turn out).

Happy scooping 🙂

Blueberry Pancake Cereal Milk Milkshake

  • Servings: 1
  • Difficulty: Easy
  • Print

Yield: 1 Milkshake


1 cup Blueberry Pancake Cap’n Crunch cereal, plus extra crushed up for garnish

1 cup plus 1/4 cup milk (choose your own adventure here, but I love whole milk in milkshakes)

4 generous scoops of vanilla ice cream (about 2 cups)

Pinch of kosher salt (optional)

Whipped cream and sprinkles (if desired)


  1. In a medium sized bowl or Pyrex-type measuring cup, combine 1 cup of cereal and 1 cup milk; let sit for one to two hours, until cereal is mooshy (mooshy not mushy, people) and the liquid is infused with the flavor of the cereal.
  2. In a blender, combine the cereal milk that you just created with ice cream, extra 1/4 cup milk, and a pinch of sea salt. Blend until desired consistency, adding more milk in very small amounts (1 tablespoon or so) until the consistency is to your liking.
  3. Pour milkshake into glasses rimmed with crushed up cereal. Top with whipped cream, more crushed up cereal, and sprinkles (if desired).
  4. Slurp through a super fun straw (mandatory).
  5. Enjoy 🙂

8 Comments Add yours

  1. Sharon says:

    My gosh, we had the same childhood! At the time, I felt like the only kid who couldn’t have fun cereal. The only cereal allowed in our house was Wheaties; and I can tell you with absolute authority that you do not become a world-class athlete from simply ingesting the product. I am so grateful that you have been able put a name to my long suffered affliction – FCFOMO! I may or may not have been tempted to lick my computer screen as I drooled over your amazing pictures. I would love to celebrate “Galentines” with you next year while, let’s just call him Bingo for purposes of this post, drives us from one ice cream shop to the next. And now that I know we also share a deep love for all cereals deemed “bad for us” by our parents, we can cap our adventure off with several bowls of said cereal and a nice half gallon of 2%! Bingo can do dishes.

    1. This sounds like an absolute perfect plan!

      And, I hope you get your full of fun cereal today – Wheaties is a classic, but eating it over and over again every single day gets a little old LOL

  2. Liz S. says:

    Your posts always have the best stories, photos, recipes – perfection 🙂

    1. Thank you so much Liz! I appreciate your support so much! ❤

  3. OMG now if you could make a Cinnamon Toast Crunch milkshake or ice cream I would book a flight to ohio like tomorrow. Golden Grahams would also do in a pinch. We mostly got Crispix and Kix when I was a kid, and we would literally spoon several tablespoons of sugar over them. The sugar would sink to the bottom of the bowl, and then we’d drink the gritty, sugar-slush cereal milk when all the cereal was gone. Kids are weird. LOL!

    1. Note to self: make Cinnamon Toast Crunch milkshakes on or around September 6th 😜 And I LOVE your creative treatment with the sugar. Dead Parents: we always find a way 😂

  4. Nicole says:

    Your food photos are the bomb. Just makes everything look mouth watering

    1. Thank you so much Nicole! If I do nothing else in life, I hope I can take photos that make people crave ice cream 🙂 Thanks for stopping by!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s